Girl Scout Study Finds That More Youth Today Say They Would Make Responsible Choices than Predecesso
A nationwide survey released December 2, 2009 by Girl Scouts of the USA finds that more American teenagers say they would make responsible decisions on a range of issues from lying and cheating to smoking and drinking than young people just a generation ago.
The study, conducted by the Girl Scout Research Institute (GSRI), is nearly identical to one Girl Scouts commissioned in 1989 and a comparison of the two shows a marked shift toward more ethical and responsible beliefs and values and civic involvement among teens and tweens.
Nearly two out of three young people (62 percent) surveyed in 2009, for example, say they would not cheat on a test compared to about half in 1989. Fifty-eight percent say they would refuse an alcoholic drink if offered one at a party. That’s compared to fewer than half (46 percent) in 1989. And only 18 percent say they believe smoking is acceptable if a person finds it enjoyable. In 1989, more than a quarter of those surveyed thought smoking was acceptable.
“This report reinforces the important role that adults play in shaping the decision-making of youth,” states Girl Scouts Western Pennsylvania, CEO, Patricia A. Burkart. “Girl Scout volunteers partner with girls to help them actualize their intentions and keep them focused on their goals, treating their personal struggles with respect and encouragement, and emphasizing how their actions and the values of the Girl Scout Law can help shape their outcomes for the future.”
The survey, Good Intentions: The Beliefs and Values of Teens and Tweens Today, involved a nationwide survey of 3,263 girls and boys from the third through twelfth grades that queried them on issues ranging from ethics and diversity to civic involvement and peer pressure. The study was conducted with Harris Interactive (formerly Louis Harris Inc., the same firm that worked on the 1989 study.)
The study also finds that one third of teenagers say they intend to wait until they are married to have sex compared to less than a quarter (24 percent) in 1989. And two decades later, youth are more accepting of gay relationships. Fifty-nine percent of teenagers agree with the statement, “Gay and lesbian relationships are OK, if that is a person’s choice.” Only 31 percent agreed in 1989.
“There’s clearly a generational change taking place,” said Kimberlee Salmond, senior researcher at GSRI and lead author of the study. “These young people strongly value diversity, acceptance and civic involvement, and almost across the board they’re more committed to these values than were their predecessors 20 years ago.”
The study also surveyed young people about issues that have become prominent with the advent of new media and technology. Only six percent say they would engage in cyberbullying by forwarding an embarrassing picture of a classmate to their friends. Some 40 percent would take the extra step of telling the originator of the e-mail what he or she did was wrong.
In addition, the data show that youth today value diversity. Among 7th- to 12th-graders, nearly six in 10 (59 percent) say that being around people from different racial and ethnic backgrounds is important to them. This appears to be particularly important to girls (63 percent versus 55 percent of boys) and youth from diverse racial or ethnic backgrounds. (This question was not asked in 1989.)
And young people today appear to have a stronger sense of civic engagement. Compared to 20 years ago, youth today are more likely to say they intend to vote in the future (84 percent vs. 77 percent), as well as give to charity (76 percent vs. 63 percent). Some 79 percent say they will volunteer in their communities.
In 2009, 105 Girl Scouts in Western Pennsylvania earned the Girl Scout Gold Award, the highest award a girl can achieve in Girl Scouting. It requires a girl to complete 65 hours of planning and implementing a community service project that represents the culmination of her experience in Girl Scouting. While this award is earned by high school students, Girl Scouts of all ages are taught to discover a concern or problem that is relevant to their neighborhood, school or home, decide upon a project to address the issue and connect with others who can help, then take action to address the issue. Girl Scouts Western Pennsylvania provides girls with ideas for these “Take Action” projects on their Web site
Compared to a decade ago, teenagers are also more likely to give to charity (80 percent of girls and 72 percent of boys) and volunteer in their community (81 percent of girls and 77 percent of boys.) For Girl Scouts, parents, educators, and youth-serving agencies, these findings offer a good counterpoint to the negative images in which teens and tweens are often depicted in our culture.